There are quite a few sheets (notably some Kirby and Zelda ones) with other errors such as missing repeat signs, missing voices,introductions, or pickup measures that definitely could be put in, and wrong/missing notes in existing voices (although this one in particular would be cumbersome to find/write for each sheet). Still, nice job!!Thanks! I would love to be able to pick out every single error for any sheet, including musical ones, but that would take an extraordinary amount of time. Hopefully, what I already have is sufficient.
Now this is an idea that I like. In fact, I have been working on something like this myself, but you have done a great job so far spotting errors in these sheets. Excellent work.If I need any help in the future, I'll be sure to let you know. ;)
If you need any further help, I would love to help you out with this. This greatly interests me.
So, for songs with a few errors would we just update it, only changing the errors, and put it back as the same person? Songs with several errors would probably require a replacement. I think that changing the URL shouldn't require re-submitting the sheet, and an updater/submitter could probably fix that.It would probably depend on the song, the sheet, and the magnitude of errors. I think at least for the moment, it would be better to focus on the ones that have the most errors, since they need replacements badly. In the future, we could maybe have a project similar to the "Replacing the URL" project for sheets with one or two errors, but that's probably going to be a lot further down the line.
I know it would take more time than it's worth, but could you simplify the musical errors to a scale of 0-5 to show how badly it would need to be edited musically? This would help the updaters a lot.You mean errors in the actual music? Because this is only a list of formatting errors. If you want a list from 0-5 (or similar) of all the formatting errors, I can do that as well.
This is awesome work Yug! I've been working on replacement arrangements lately and it's really hard to decide what to work on through the 3000+ sheets... This will help massively.Thanks! Glad to hear you'll get some use out of this thing!
The ability to comment on the document would also be nice for a few misc things I've noticedYeah, I'm not sure I want to open it up to comments just yet. If you wanted to let me know of any discrepancies, just send me a PM.how do?(https://www.ninsheetmusic.org/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2Fwtwsmue.png&hash=fe74022bace4f39e4110c9352f65a159)
↓↓↓↓↓↓↓
(https://www.ninsheetmusic.org/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2F3ZjEjD1.png&hash=9ab25fceb8fcef6a5075e3be75dd3329)
↓↓↓↓↓↓↓
(https://www.ninsheetmusic.org/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2FipqhXNS.png&hash=5d5f9fda7a369f7bf7e0065e4f6e249f)[close]
One suggestion I can think of: the division of games is a bit confusing to read through. A system of alternating colors ought to be easier to read, but it might take a while to do. If you feel up to it sometime though, it'd be a nice touch ;)brb, totally stealing thisSpoiler(https://www.ninsheetmusic.org/forum/proxy.php?request=http%3A%2F%2Fi.imgur.com%2Fz3XGuOR.png&hash=9d963298ddb399d1bcb39fd429a89e6f)[close]
You mean errors in the actual music? Because this is only a list of formatting errors. If you want a list from 0-5 (or similar) of all the formatting errors, I can do that as well.Well, you see, if it's a 1 in musical errors and a 5 in formatting, it's not inconceivable that an updater could fix that up pretty quickly. You see, formatting is not all that makes a sheet good. Yes, we could fix up the site, but, if we don't change the fact that some of the arrangements are downright bad, it's like polishing a turd. It may be polished. but it's still a turd. The hit list for edits and replacements shouldn't be limited to just formatting is what I'm getting at. That said, I by no means am trying to belittle the tremendous amount of time you poured into this. It's quite incredible. Thank you.
Well, you see, if it's a 1 in musical errors and a 5 in formatting, it's not inconceivable that an updater could fix that up pretty quickly. You see, formatting is not all that makes a sheet good. Yes, we could fix up the site, but, if we don't change the fact that some of the arrangements are downright bad, it's like polishing a turd. It may be polished. but it's still a turd. The hit list for edits and replacements shouldn't be limited to just formatting is what I'm getting at. That said, I by no means am trying to belittle the tremendous amount of time you poured into this. It's quite incredible. Thank you.I completely understand. While I was doing this, I figured the most important thing was that users knew which sheets needed replacing. Once they had one or more sheets to work on, I figured they would look into the music themselves to see what needed fixing. I guess this mentality only works if you're working on one or two at a time & not a whole swath of sheets.
If you want the musical errors on the table, there are plenty of us willing to help check the sheets.We'd have to come up with a quantifiable system, and get quite a few volunteers, but I'm open to this suggestion.
We'd have to come up with a quantifiable system.I think a good system would be to rate sheets based on the amount of errors, but then there's the struggle of major errors over minor errors. I don't have too many ideas on that part.
A very patient & dedicated one, at that!You forgot OCD.
*Sheet lists Gamer4250 as the arranger, despite KefkaticFanatic being the arranger credited on sitekek
Butterfly | Brawler4Ever | There's actually nothing wrong with the formatting, but this song is actually licensed from Smile.dk's album "Smile", and I believe that we don't allow licensed songs, yes? So this song should be taken down?
This song was done about a forever ago. I actually don't know the exact protocol. If we want it removed, I have no objections. :)I'd say check with the updaters first, but to my knowledge we don't allow licensed songs on-site.
Today's update added a total of 17 replacements,Hey that's pretty ne--
19 of whichwat
your url failedWhich one? All links appear to be working at the moment.
[url(=) http://THE MATH WORKS OUT, I SWEAR][/url]
I'd also note that, yes, the Balloon Fight sheet under Melee is supposed to be under Balloon Fight as "Bonus Round". Same song.I just have whatever's listed on-site in the Audit. Whether or not the title is correct and/or under the correct game series is a different problem entirely. But hey, good to see you're making this problem known.
Fire Emblem is officially the first series to be completely replaced!
Next up: KirbyNot until the "Taking Over the Halberd" sheet gets replaced, which I suspect won't be for a long while.
Fire Emblem is officially the first series to be completely replaced!
Not until the "Taking Over the Halberd" sheet gets replaced, which I suspect won't be for a long while.I have both in progress actually
(And I also suspect that no one wants to clean up Marx's theme.)
Can we just take a moment to appreciate Yug
We look forward to seeing you once you recover from that sick burn.
Pin it to make it official official.(https://media.giphy.com/media/3o84sE0JO6pwfWV9i8/giphy.gif)
- Xenoblade section is now entirely up to standard!
Kirby Super StarAt last! A far cry from where we used to be five years ago (https://web.archive.org/web/20150122091651/http://www.ninsheetmusic.org/browse/series/Kirby) ;D