News:

Up-to-date news?! Preposterous!

Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Maelstrom

#16
Feedback / Re: The Great NSM Auditâ„¢ 2.0
October 02, 2022, 09:07:41 AM
10 sheets were removed in the past 2 months
that's pretty cool
as such, the sheet has been updated
#17
Off-Topic / Re: hi
September 30, 2022, 06:35:35 AM
It's not just that, forums are kinda antithetical to the mobile experience as the layouts just don't work there (and no one really made mobile versions anyway).
If discord was still just desktop only, I don't think we'd be having this conversation.
#18
Off-Topic / Re: hi
September 29, 2022, 07:06:46 PM
woah
someone who outdates me congrats

honestly wish this forum was still more active but pretty much everything aside from sheet updates have moved to the discord server unfortunately.....

I miss forums in general
#19
If you set it using the document>pickup measure, I think it doesn't count it as 1....
If it still does, use the measure tool and double click on the top of the 2 boxes for that measure and uncheck the box that says "include in measure numbering"
#20
ok lets try this again

-I hear an F restrike in RH m20. Well, really, that layer doesn't come in until then even if it's implied by the chord, but it makes sense to have a restrike.

Genuinely not sure what I was talking about with the m27/18 thing. I don't hear weird stuff in any combination of measures ending in 7/8 so I'm sorry? I'm sure this is making me seem like a very stable human being........

What you have for m37-38 is cool

going to approve pending m20 comment before I make myself look more psychotic
#21
Quote from: Libera on September 23, 2022, 10:26:45 AMI tried my best but it is a bit of a nightmare to make out.  Let me know if you have any better ideas.
My only better idea is not to arrange music like this lol

I think it's cool as is. You understand about as much as I was saying about m18 as I do now. I think it was something about it sounding off, but yeah all the notes are there and simply moving dissonances shared between instruments to piano is going to make it sound a bit different.

accept
#23
Quote from: Libera on September 23, 2022, 09:34:57 AMAlthough I do now notice that I think the bass actually goes to a D on beat 12 of bar 6 (just before the C in the following bar).  Not super clear, but it seems right to me.  Also, is the C rearticulated on beat 7 of bar 3?  It kind of sounds like it to me.
I can't hear anything in there and would prefer to leave it as is, since that's the simplest way of putting it, imo

Fixed m10, I think everyone will be fine with it now

I still don't know what you're going on about latios, I can't hear that F# and certainly not any vocal harmonies there.......
#24
both good suggestions, changes made

for the record, redraw is ctrl+u but it didn't seem to work for this.....
#25
all good suggestions

lemme know how that looks
#26
My only other comment is the grace note->slured pair of 8th notes looks really bad on the PDF. I'd recommend either moving the slurs or making it a single slur because that's really hard to read as is.
Otherwise it looks good
#27
I meant m8, not m9. You currently have a rest where I hear the note.

Idk, I hear the G pretty strong. Lemme call in a 2nd opinion.
#30
you need to zoom in as much as physically possible when aligning stuff you manually input
or have a high res screen like me and eyes that notice crap like this\

edit: both doesnt hurt either