31
Piano Arrangements / Re: The Deku Trombonist's Arrangements
« on: April 02, 2020, 01:33:13 PM »
What's this?? Another new video??? It must be the virus...
Interested in contributing to the site? Give The Arrangement Formatting Guidelines and The Arranging Checklist a good read!
Mine’s coming up too. Deku, things were really different back then, weren’t they? HahaThey sure were! We had lots of fun and some spectacular arguments too but lots of memories anyway.
(Also I think your Fluffy Bluff Galaxy arrangement was one of the first arrangements I learned back then, Super Mario Galaxy 2 had just released when i joined)Yeesh, that is going back a while. I was really taken by Fluffy Bluff Galaxy, I even transcribed the whole track as-is for orchestra. I'm glad you liked it anyway. Hopefully, all things going well, you should start seeing plenty more sheets from me in the not too distant future.
Yes.[/list]Is it really that important that the performer gets it right on the first read?
attempt at coming up with a decent username
I have made a few edit replacements of other sheets in the past ... I always thought it was fine to do this just as any other kind of replacement.Yeah I know how things are done around here, even though I don't agree with it. But having been an updater before, I know what it's like and what effect it can have, so I'm not blaming you personally. Just remember that everyone is different and has different wishes, so it's always a good idea to check, even if it's just a courtesy because you're pretty sure what the answer is going to be.
including another by youOh? I didn't know about this.
But, your original arrangement doesn't really have any issues (in terms of notes, etc.) and mine is just re-arranging it for the most part.I wasn't suggesting that mine was perfect or anything like that (if there even can be a perfect arrangement). I just don't want my name on something that wasn't my work, or to have things changed without my knowledge.
I don't think it's as worthwhile an edit as I originally thought now that I'm looking at the sheet again. I'm just going to remove it from this update.Why call it an edit? It's your arrangement so why not call it as such? Incidentally, I think this is one of those times where the one sheet policy doesn't do this place any favours.
The main focus of this submission will be figuring out the first measure...I've got a version I did back in my last arranging spree in 2016 or so. I'll see if I can dig it up tonight or tomorrow and give you some food for thought.