The "Fixing the Sheets" Initiative 2.0 - Current Target: Pokémon R/B *Done!*

[Latios212]

There wasn't much in the third voice. Not that I found anyway. What I did find was an interference with the melody; most of the notes in the third voice were covered by the chords present in the melody anyway. I added a total of 4 notes. Not exactly sure if that covers "being edited," so I left the sheet in dahans' name.

No that's just the thing; the chords aren't supposed to be there. The melody is just single notes and the bottom notes in the chords are imagined and should be replaced with the independent second voice in a separate layer. (Compare the on-site version of Cinnabar Island with the one in the Dropbox folder for an example of what I mean when it comes to dahans' stuff.)

[flygon9]

Hey, it seems I'm kinda late for the party, but is Pallet Town still up for grabs?

[Latios212]

Hey, no problem! We'd appreciate your help!

I think I finished Pallet Town, though. You can check it out in the dropbox folder (link somewhere above) and tell me if there are any mistakes. Here are the sheets that need the most fixes right now:

"Title Screen" - Needs to be split up into "Opening Movie" and "Title Screen" as Yellow shares the same Title Screen theme. It still has many wrong notes from dahans' old sheet and note durations need to be checked as well.
"Professor Oak's Laboratory" - Third voice completely incorrect.
"Silph Co." - accidental checking, among other things.
"Opening (Yellow)" - This one's a little messy...

[flygon9]

Well I'll do what I can with Notepad. And I'm gonna be away for a week, so it'll be a little while, but I'll see what I can do.

[Pianist Da Sootopolis]

Many thanks!

[Tobbeh99]

JD update list colors!

[JDMEK5]

Haha I'm-a comin'!

EDIT: Now we need to figure out what we're gonna do regarding custom endings. Yes or no? I know that Bespinben is a supporter and while I kinda agree, I personally think that it has to depend on the situation and the way it's given. To justify a custom ending for me it would have to be at least somewhat elaborate and not just a cadence or something else just kinda thrown in. Thoughts?

ALSO: There's some discrepancy regarding "game name" on some sheets. Some read "Pokémon Red/Blue Version" while others read "Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow Version". Obviously the tracks that are Yellow Version exclusive will just read "Pokémon Yellow Version" only but should we have all three game names for those to which it applies?

[Latios212]

I'll post my thoughts on custom endings later cuz I'm kinda busy but for game name, I'd say Red/Blue Version mainly because the other type of naming would get messy when we get to gen 5.

[JDMEK5]

Would it though? How so?

ALSO: In the dropbox folder I added a text file explaining in detail the calculation for the percentile on the Target Post. Just in case you guys were wondering. Truth actually is that it's mainly there so I don't forget it next time it needs updating.

[Latios212]

Either way works fine up until gen 5 where we'd have to combine "Pokémon Black/White Version" and "Pokémon Black/White Version 2"which would get really messy.

[JDMEK5]

But they're two different pairs of games. This time we did Gen 1 but if we did Gen 5, we'd prob do them separately or at least view them separately. For tracks that appear in both pairs I would actually have them relisted on the site under both names.

[Latios212]

But most of the BW songs were carried over to BW2 just as the entire OST of RB appears in Yellow. We wouldn't re-list 45 tracks from RB under Yellow, and similarly we wouldn't want to list the BW OST twice.

Anyway this isn't that relevant right now, so is sticking with "Pokémon Red/Blue Version" fine? It doesn't really matter to me as long as we keep it consistent.

[Tobbeh99]

I think we'd write "Pokémon Red/Blue/Yellow" simply because the song are in yellow too, and they're are under the same category. I'd say black & White is a different case and that we should focus on Gen 1.

[JDMEK5]

I'd say black & White is a different case and that we should focus on Gen 1.

I definitely agree with that.

But most of the BW songs were carried over to BW2 just as the entire OST of RB appears in Yellow. We wouldn't re-list 45 tracks from RB under Yellow, and similarly we wouldn't want to list the BW OST twice

Actually while that's true, most of the BW2 reiterations are modified from the original. So rearranging them is fully reasonable. Unless I'm forgetting some cases.

[Tobbeh99]

Concerning the song list in OP. What happened to Jigglypuff's song? And isn't pallet town done?