TWG CXVII: The Lantern Keeper Redux

[XiaoMigros]

bds i think you're the strange man

[BlackDragonSlayer]

bds i think you're the strange man

some people may say i'm a strange man, sure, but i am not the strange man

[Oricorio]

In a night start game I'd say it's too early to even start considering those sort of takes, especially because most's people first posts are just going to be jokes that are completely irrespective of their role. It's very easy to accidentally taint your own reasoning by making a loose take too early and tunneling it; personally, I generally wait until the end of the first night phase or beginning of the first day phase to make a more formal suspicion list.

Lame. It's never too early to start pursuing leads. You have read your role PM, have you not? And thus, you are keeping in mind your alignment when you are writing posts.

[XiaoMigros]

some people may say i'm a strange man, sure, but i am not the strange man

sounds like something the strange man would say...

[Oricorio]

bds i think you're the strange man

Do you have any reason for your suspicions?

[XiaoMigros]

just the vibe tbh, and how hes responded to my accusations

[Oricorio]

just the vibe tbh, and how hes responded to my accusations

Do you have a read on A# Minor?

[BlackDragonSlayer]

Lame. It's never too early to start pursuing leads.

I disagree. Not even half the players in the game have posted yet, and I think we should give more time for others to show up and voice their thoughts before judging people too much based on their interactions.

You have read your role PM, have you not? And thus, you are keeping in mind your alignment when you are writing posts.

I don't think it's a stretch that many players think of what they're gonna say for their first post before PMs are even sent out. Regardless, this early in the game most people aren't even thinking that far ahead and are just acting how they would regardless of role.

[Oricorio]

I was probably about to miss the entire first phase because I forgot about this. it was the most adequate thing to say

Well, now that you've "reported for duty", is there anything you're going to do?

[XiaoMigros]

Do you have a read on A# Minor?

my read on A# Minor has historically always been wrong

[A# Minor]

Well, now that you've "reported for duty", is there anything you're going to do?

observe

[Oricorio]

I disagree. Not even half the players in the game have posted yet, and I think we should give more time for others to show up and voice their thoughts before judging people too much based on their interactions.

But people have shown up, and why waste an opportunity to get more information out of them? Sure, it would be ideal to talk to everybody but for now we have to use what we've got

I don't think it's a stretch that many players think of what they're gonna say for their first post before PMs are even sent out. Regardless, this early in the game most people aren't even thinking that far ahead and are just acting how they would regardless of role.

But they still have to type in the post after they've received their role PM. And if people aren't planning ahead, then it's a good opportunity to catch wolves off-guard, is it not?

[Oricorio]

my read on A# Minor has historically always been wrong

Then give your read, and we'll just have to follow the opposite of it!

[Oricorio]

observe

Do you have any thoughts on Dragon or Xiao so far?

[Oricorio]

But they still have to type in the post after they've received their role PM. And if people aren't planning ahead, then it's a good opportunity to catch wolves off-guard, is it not?

Damn, I am not good at this site's quote system