What are you playing right now?

[MaestroUGC]

A bunch of super nitpicky stuff about a game I don't have direct experience with.

The whole point of a review is to review something you have experienced. Watching a Walkthrough, Let's Play, Speed run, or anything like that is not a direct experience.

That's like me reviewing a movie I heard described by a friend.

[Sebastian]

But you haven't experienced it so your opinion is shit.

Doubtful
As I said, my opinion

[blueflower999]

It's his thread, let him do what he wants. 

Although, I would suggest adding a note to the review saying that you don't have any first-hand experience with the game. Just for clarification.

[mikey]

It's his thread, let him do what he wants. 

Although, I would suggest adding a note to the review saying that you don't have any first-hand experience with the game. Just for clarification.

Good guy blue :p

[BlackDragonSlayer]

Some games are so bad you just know they're bad before you play them.

[MaestroUGC]

But it's in the playing of them that makes it so special.

[FierceDeity]

But you haven't experienced it so your opinion is shit.

^^
Seriously what the hell haha. Like, I know none of us are professional critics or anything, but imagine reading a film review by somebody who never watched the film. Most respectable critics watch a film twice at a minimum. Maybe we don't expect that much from game reviews, but we still go in assuming that the reviewer has some level of expertise or above average knowledge concerning the game, of which you clearly have neither if you haven't played it... Especially considering your entire review was essentially "This game isn't exactly like TTYD!", a reservation which might have been resolved by playing the game, and realizing "Oh wait this wasn't SUPPOSED to be a cookie cutter sequel."

[Sebastian]

^^
Seriously what the hell haha. Like, I know none of us are professional critics or anything, but imagine reading a film review by somebody who never watched the film. Most respectable critics watch a film twice at a minimum. Maybe we don't expect that much from game reviews, but we still go in assuming that the reviewer has some level of expertise or above average knowledge concerning the game, of which you clearly have neither if you haven't played it... Especially considering your entire review was essentially "This game isn't exactly like TTYD!", a reservation which might have been resolved by playing the game, and realizing "Oh wait this wasn't SUPPOSED to be a cookie cutter sequel."

This is a little offensive. I dont JUST like TTYD. I like all 3. And the 4th isn't like any of them.
Well.....I did say for the 3rd time, "My Opinion."
And a walkthrough is technically playing it.
I know your mad at me but dont just flame everything I say please.

[mikey]

Twilight Princess or Spirit Tracks next?
Just assume I've never played either

[Sebastian]

Twilight Princess or Spirit Tracks next?
Just assume I've never played either

Of what I've heard, Twilight Princess.

[InfinitySoul]

Twilight Princess or Spirit Tracks next?
Just assume I've never played either

Twilight Princess is my favorite Zelda game plus is the first one I ever played! So go with that!

[Kman96]

I'M DOING A THREE-HEART CHALLENGE ON LINK BETWEEN WORLDS. IT'S NOT TOO BAD RIGHT NOW, BUT I JUST GOTTA FIND ONE MORE BOTTLE AND JACK MYSELF UP ON FAIRIES.

OML I LOVE THIS GAME SO MUCH ITS SO MUCH FUN.

[SuperFireKirby]

Twilight Princess, I feel, gets way more flack than it deserves because it was legitimately a FANTASTIC game. Not my favorite LoZ, albeit, but still incredible in it's own right. And it was milessss better than Spirit Tracks

Also reviewing a game you haven't played is bullshit. Goho-M

[McDucky]

Twilight Princess

Yes, I absolutely loved it. It's almost as high up on my list as OoT.

[SlowPokemon]

Goho-M

ha