TWG LVIII - The Boy's Forest of Tears [Evaluation]

[Toby]

I forgot to mention that the wolves could use their own boxes and not need to give them away.

And to be fair, the game had 18 people, it was bound to be a week longer than usual TWG's. Also, 3 weeks isn't even that long for a TWG. And Waddle, I know it's not nice having people banned from your game but it's how the rules work and if they were going to be banned from my next game, then that's me lost 5 votes in the next host signup poll and even worse, those 5 votes would probably be given to another TWG. Potentially making a 10 vote difference.

[Waddle Bro]

I sure as hell ain't banning people from my game because of this.

[Bird]

We're still talking about the issue.

There's four factors which make by-the-rules bans a bad idea.

1. Over 25% of the game would be banned if we followed the rules explicitly.
2. Even though the change was made months ago, I feel like a lot of people weren't familiar with the "two phantoms and you're out" rule.
3. Phantoms weren't tracked during the game, and
4. The following game is anonymous. By banning people, it would become clear that those players weren't participating, which is no fun at all.

If we do take action, it will likely be for the one following Waddle's.