Tgamer240's Arrangements (Updated 8/2/09!)

[Nintendude73]

Airship theme rejected for now, please format your sheet correctly, try to fix the squished notes.  I realize there's supposed to be some dissonance at certain parts but it still just kind of rubs me the wrong way...

[Tgamer240]

What about Route 1? It's in the submission part now.

[Nintendude73]

Now we've got two Route 1s vying for a spot on the site.  Which one do you guys prefer?

Echo's or Tgamer240's?

[Tgamer240]

Mine, because 1. I think I did a pretty good job, and 2. I am unable to download files via mediafire.

[master_gamer38]

No offense Tgamer240, but I think echo's sheet is better. Yours to me seems just to be the melody line. While echo's sheet has the harmonies too.

[Tgamer240]

No offense Tgamer240, but I think echo's sheet is better. Yours to me seems just to be the melody line. While echo's sheet has the harmonies too.

None taken master_gamer38, and I agree that echo's sheet is pretty good. My sheet, however, is simpler, and can be easily played by those starting out.
...you're wondering why I said none taken, aren't you? Well, you said no offense, and I said none taken. XD

[Tgamer240]

Nintendude73, what are your opinions on echo's sheet and my sheet? Be honest.

[Tgamer240]

I've Updated my Airship theme now! It's in the submission list.

[blah54]

your route 1 arrangement isn't bad... i don't know what happened to the previous version on the site, but it was pretty good...

random_goldfish also has a piano arrangement of this as well, which admittedly sounds better, not that yours is bad though... and between hers and echo's... they're both very similar...

as for your (Tgamer240), ruby and sapphire gym leader battle... it sounds pretty good... bars 38-40, isn't there something else going on as well? bars 49-50 is the wrong note in the right hand... bars 51-54 i think it constant eighth notes... no tied notes, but im not sure...

but pretty good job on it...

[Echo]

After looking at the other sheets, I'm really leaning toward my own to be on the site right now. I'm not saying that out of selfishness or arrogance or anything, it's just that I don't like how Tgamer's is written out (no key sig, looks awkward when compared to mine and random_goldfish's etc.), and between mine and random_goldfish's, mine is more correct in terms of details like the background parts and the bass pitches. The tempo I have is more accurate too.

[Beethoven II]

Tgamer240: are you really going to keep that FlatZone duet?

[Tgamer240]

Well, you never know if it will make it.

[Tgamer240]

All right, Echo, I'll let your Route 1 piece go on.

[FallenPianist]

Your Wii Sports theme arrangement is nice

there is some chords that you should change, like the first in measure 21, it's almost impossible to play. i think that if you have C, E, G, C, then again E, you can remove the last E, so that will make a nice 4-notes chords. I don't know if you understand, but, it's a great arrangement.

[Lildigipoke2]

Wii Sports sound great but the notes are too squished