Be sure to tell your friends about NinSheetMusic!
Started by Kaiveran, September 21, 2023, 10:52:01 PM
Quote from: Toby on September 24, 2023, 04:01:19 PMunless inactives are cold targets, they aren't going to be the subject of a night kill
QuoteI just think it's so easy during early day phases to vote someone for being a bit extra or a bit excited, or making an honest mistake and inactives just fly under the radar.
QuoteIf we avoid lynching an active player today it also means we have more content to base our suspicions on by next day phase, whereas math guy seems like he'll make maybe 2 more posts by day 2 lol
Quote from: Toby on September 24, 2023, 04:14:28 PM@BDS just to note : I don't think I've agreed with Davy on anything if I'm to be honestI didn't agree with his plansAnd I made a comment that certain things shouldn't be revealed to topic which Davy followed up and agreed with me on
QuoteBut saying that I'm not sure if you've also realised that since your suspicion paragraph on me seems to go round in a circle where you realise I haven't actually agreed with Davy as you apparently though so lol
Quote from: Toby on September 24, 2023, 01:24:25 PMThat was my feeling too, and because I was just called neutral and Specs was called townie. I wonder if Specs could be THC's ward and he's paid extra attention to trying to make him look positive to the topic.Alternatively maybe I'm his ward and he's just wanted me to appear vague as to not be a wolfing target. It could also just be genuine and maybe I'm being held to a higher standard as I was more active last game lol
Quote from: threalmathguy on September 24, 2023, 04:24:10 PMShoot, I forgot that wards were known to assassins, that's gonna change how I think of things. This is very valid.
Quote from: BlackDragonSlayer on September 24, 2023, 04:11:00 PM1. I disagree with that, given the possibility than inactive can still be hot targets or any other target an assassin might have an interest in killing.2. Fair point. I don't think an inactive lynch is inherently bad, just imo we have better targets already, and there's no reason to needlessly stall the game. If there weren't any good targets I'd be inclined to fully agree with you.3. Also fair, but an alternative is that everybody makes an effort to be more active rather than than a few players being "the active player." Generally throughout the course of a game, I'd say it's a good idea if activity is roughly equivalently distributed rather than one or two players completely monopolizing the discussion.
Quote from: Toby on September 24, 2023, 04:28:55 PM1. I mean sure they could be hot targets, but with math for example, he's posting so little it would be difficult for the assassin's to read him as a hot target. I'm not sure what strategy an assassin might have in trying to find their hot targets, but I'd probably just target players as normal and hope towards end of game the hot targets die by default
Quote2. I mean that's your opinion. I just think often day 1 it's the more enthusiastic players that make a slip up and get read wrong and being enthusiastic doesn't inherently make you either wolfy or human. This would match Davys case where he's being read for swaying his opinion and trying to come up with strategies when that could all just be genuine day 1 enthusiasm. Xiao is another suspicion I guess which I could consider because he actually has been quieter than last game, where he threw out a lot more jokes and filler posts during day 1 compared to this game. Xiao also was incredibly hard to read in the end game LYLO. But I still honestly detest letting someone who has posted twice stay over others lol
Quote3. I mean sure but will math guy for example be more active ? Magnet promised to be more active last game many times and didn't
QuoteWe also don't really know how many mislynches we have this game and as the game goes on we will naturally have more content and 'evidence' against players who are more active which will make us less inclined to lynch an inactive posting twice a phase lol. I'll at least feel better going into day 2 knowing math guy isn't there and don't need to consider him lol, whereas if we lynched an active player and they're a normal human I'll have regrets we don't have their opinions around going into day 2 and we didn't give them a chance
Quote from: BlackDragonSlayer on September 24, 2023, 04:44:53 PMAnd given how sporadically mathguy has posted, if he's a hot target, do you think he would be around close enough to the end of the phase for him to claim as a hot target (and for us to wait long enough to see if anyone counterclaims) AND for us to not scramble for a backup lynch?
Quote from: Toby on September 24, 2023, 04:01:19 PMVoting math for literally only posting twice this game and the only real take they gave was on TZP their irl friend which feels forced.
Quote from: threalmathguy on September 23, 2023, 08:59:15 PMI'm down for the strategy of townies taking one for the team, drawing attention to anyone defending themselves or pushing for an alternate lynch.That being said, I'm also a bit sus on TZP claiming hot target immediately. It seems like the outcomes hurt the town more than they help. It could be a gamble for ward, but the odds are against us on that. And even if he's telling the truth, surely one of the assassins will try to call his bluff at some point.I've seen some of your opinions on this, what does everyone else think?
Page created in 0.102 seconds with 22 queries.