Arrangement Project (Paper Mario)

[DonValentino]

I think all that's left is accept the already arranged sheets. But yeah, this AP is stagnant atm

[FierceDeity]

Preemptive self-quote:

why do people always blame slow updates on the updaters
instead of the arrangers whose sheets they have to fix

[DonValentino]

Just to be clear, I didn't blame anyone, I just said that all that's left is accept the arranged sheets because that is what's actually left to do with this (and of course, a sheet must be fixed in order to be accepted :p).

[FierceDeity]

No yeah, that's why I said it was preemptive these conversations just tend to devolve into "UGH UPDATERS FIX CHECK MY SHEETS ALREADY"

Also wait how the shit has nobody taken/done A Kingdom in Chaos yet
Like, a lot of these I have trouble seeing how I could make it work/be interesting as a piano arrangement (lookin at you mt. lavalava), but not this one, so fuck it, I'll take this one as long as the project's still in limbo

[Sebastian]

No yeah, that's why I said it was preemptive these conversations just tend to devolve into "UGH UPDATERS FIX CHECK MY SHEETS ALREADY"

Also wait how the shit has nobody taken/done A Kingdom in Chaos yet
Like, a lot of these I have trouble seeing how I could make it work/be interesting as a piano arrangement (lookin at you mt. lavalava), but not this one, so fuck it, I'll take this one as long as the project's still in limbo

Great

[King Sammer]

Mr. L, Green Thunder!

Maybe Brobot Battle...

[Maelstrom]

Mr. L, Green Thunder!

Maybe Brobot Battle...

Paper Mario.
Not Super Paper Mario.

[Sebastian]

Mr. L, Green Thunder!

Maybe Brobot Battle...

Paper Mario only.
Sorry...

[Maelstrom]

Will this enter review now that the holidays are upon us?

[Sebastian]

I'm guessing yes....

[The Deku Trombonist]

Bloop:

Kammy Koopa's Theme
-Needs a major reworking

Snow Road
-Tempo is a fraction too slow
-Most of the chords need fixing up

Gates of Goomba Castle
-Bars 4-5 could be notated clearer
-Same with bar 9 which can mostly be in one layer
-The end of bar 7 would probably make it look like a 5/4 bar when printed

[Sebastian]

Any feedback on mine?

[FierceDeity]

He hasn't forgotten it, he just hasn't gotten to it yet. Relax.

[Bloop]

Kammy Koopa's Theme
-Needs a major reworking

Is this enough reworking?

Snow Road
-Tempo is a fraction too slow
-Most of the chords need fixing up

This should do the trick, although I'm not sure about the chords. They weird, but I tried my best.

Gates of Goomba Castle
-Bars 4-5 could be notated clearer
-Same with bar 9 which can mostly be in one layer
-The end of bar 7 would probably make it look like a 5/4 bar when printed

I prefer to keep bar 9 as it is, as the layers are two different voices (see previous bar). Fixed 4-5 and 7 though

[Maelstrom]

Two questions.
1. It has been 3 1/2 months since the last piece was arranged. Maybe it's time to consider the project closed.......

2. I understand the reasoning behind not letting the next arrangement project start until the current one is finished: So there is not multiple projects waiting for review simultaneously. However, if the current project is closed, even if the review process goes slowly, it should be completed by the time the next project is finished.